Established practice

Clinicians are brilliant at care and expensive about everything else

When clinical and commercial priorities aren't aligned, you absorb the gap, in wasted capacity, unapproved spend, and decisions made without any sense of margin. Most clinic owners never close it.

steps: 6; steps
to start: 2 hours; to start

The short answer

Clinicians are not uncommercial, they just never see the numbers. Share a small set of figures each month, explain how their decisions on scheduling, follow-ups, coding and documentation affect them, and agree measures together. The aim is shared understanding, not turning clinicians into salespeople.

6 steps

Do it yourself: step by step

0 of 6 done

Choose 5 figures clinicians can influence: session utilisation, DNA rate, follow-up booking rate, letter turnaround, insurer rejections linked to coding or documentation
Time
2 hours
Typical cost
£0
Who does it
practice manager
Done when: Five agreed measures defined

This problem is Solvable.

Copy this table

Monthly clinician dashboard

Free to copy, adapt and use. No sign-up.

Table

Monthly clinician dashboard

Clinician: [name] Month: [month]

Measure	You	Clinic average	Target	Why it matters
Session utilisation	[ ]%	[ ]%	[ ]%	Empty slots cost room and staff time with no income
DNA rate	[ ]%	[ ]%	[ ]%	Each missed slot is lost income and a longer wait for others
Follow-ups booked on the day	[ ]%	[ ]%	[ ]%	Patients who leave without booking often do not return
Letter turnaround (working days)	[ ]	[ ]	[ ]	Referrers notice slow letters
Insurer rejections linked to coding or notes	[ ]	[ ]	0	Each rejection delays or loses payment

One thing that went well: [ ] One thing to look at next month: [ ]

Session outline (60 to 90 minutes)

Where our income comes from (payer mix)
What a session costs to run
What happens when a slot is empty
How insurers decide whether to pay
Your figures and what you can influence
Your ideas

Avoid these

Common mistakes

Sharing only revenue, which feels like pressure to see more patients.
Sending figures without context or comparison.
Blaming clinicians for insurer rejections without explaining the rules.
Imposing targets rather than agreeing them.
Treating commercial awareness as a one-off training session.

Free personal check

Done by Paul Robinson, not software

Answer eight quick questions and I'll show you where your clinicians are missing the numbers

What I need from you

Eight tap answers about how you share numbers with clinicians
Your clinic type and number of clinicians

What you get

How you compare with clinics that share numbers well
The three gaps that cost you most
A simple monthly pack you can start next month

Within 2 working days

No sign-in, no sales call. I read every request myself and reply on WhatsApp.

Free tools

Check where you stand

Your illustrative estimate

£20,500

Solvable estimate. Rounded to the nearest £500. Updates as you type.

Empty slots per week

Starting figure 10 (from 10 (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Average slot value

Starting figure £150 (from £150 (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Share of empty slots clinicians can influence

Starting figure 25% (from 25% (Solvable estimate: most gaps come from demand and scheduling)). Change it to match your practice.

Rejections per month

Starting figure 8 (from 8 (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Average claim value

Starting figure £250 (from £250 (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Share never recovered

Starting figure 25% (from 25% (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Share preventable

Starting figure 50% (from 50% (Solvable estimate)). Change it to match your practice.

Formula

Recoverable annual income = (empty bookable slots per week x average slot value x 46 weeks x share clinicians can influence) + (insurer rejections per month x average claim value x share never recovered x 12 x share preventable by better coding and notes)

Variables and defaults

empty slots per week: 10 (Solvable estimate)
average slot value: £150 (Solvable estimate)
share of empty slots clinicians can influence: 25% (Solvable estimate: most gaps come from demand and scheduling)
rejections per month: 8 (Solvable estimate)
average claim value: £250 (Solvable estimate)
share never recovered: 25% (Solvable estimate)
share preventable: 50% (Solvable estimate)

Defaults only. Change them in the calculator to use your own numbers.

Assumptions and defaults

empty slots per week = 10 (Solvable estimate)
average slot value = £150 (Solvable estimate)
share of empty slots clinicians can influence = 25% (Solvable estimate: most gaps come from demand and scheduling)
rejections per month = 8 (Solvable estimate)
average claim value = £250 (Solvable estimate)
share never recovered = 25% (Solvable estimate)
share preventable = 50% (Solvable estimate)

Empty slots and lost claims cost about £75,000 a year at these defaults (context, arithmetic checked: £69,000 + £6,000). The share clinicians can realistically influence is about £20,000 a year (£17,250 + £3,000).

Every supplier I know who solves this. No one pays to be listed. Where I've worked with them, I say so.

Medical Billing & Collection
Billing and revenue
Outsourced billing, insurer e-billing and patient payment collection for private consultants, groups and clinics, charged on income collected.
Outsourced insurer and self-pay billing for consultants and small clinics, if you would rather not chase invoices.
Best for: Consultants wanting fully outsourced billing
Price on request
No commercial relationship
Semble
Practice management software
Practice management and patient records software for private clinics and consultants, covering scheduling, notes, telehealth and payments.
Clinic PMS covering bookings, notes, invoicing, online payments and a patient portal in one place.
Best for: Private consultants, clinics and clinic groups
Price on request
No commercial relationship
Trust Health
Billing and revenue
Medical billing, debt recovery and business support for private consultants and consultant partnerships (LLPs).
Outsourced billing and debt collection for consultants and consultant partnerships, based in Horsham.
Best for: Consultants and consultant partnerships
Price on request
No commercial relationship

Know a supplier I have missed? Tell me Suggest yourself

The gap between clinical and commercial thinking is one of the most common sources of tension in independent healthcare. Clinicians are trained to optimise for patient outcomes; the business needs them to also understand capacity, margin, and growth. These are not incompatible, but the bridge has to be built deliberately.

The primary root cause is the fundamental difference in training and professional focus between clinical and commercial roles.
Clinicians are rigorously trained to prioritise patient care and ethical considerations, often with limited exposure to business operations, financial management, or market dynamics during their education.
This creates a systemic gap in understanding the commercial pressures and opportunities faced by private healthcare organisations.
Behaviourally, this can lead to a perception of conflicting priorities, where commercial decisions are viewed with suspicion or as secondary to clinical excellence, fostering friction rather than collaboration.

No verified UK data available

Suboptimal resource utilisation leading to longer patient waiting lists
Increased administrative burden due to non-standardised processes
Reduced profitability margins impacting investment in new technology or staff development
Increased operational costs due to inefficient practices
Perception of disorganisation or inefficiency by patients and referrers
Difficulty attracting and retaining commercially aware clinical talent

What it looks like in practice

Clinicians ordering expensive, non-formulary items without considering cost-effective alternatives
Scheduling practices that optimise for clinical convenience over patient flow and capacity utilisation
Reluctance to engage with private medical insurance (PMI) processes or understand billing complexities
Missed opportunities for service development or market differentiation due to a narrow clinical focus

Paul Robinson

14 years in UK private healthcare

I solve this one for clinic and hospital teams

Want a hand? I'll look at your situation and tell you the three things I'd tackle first.

A few quick questions, about two minutes. I read every one myself and usually reply the same day.

No sales call unless you ask for one. Just a straight answer from me.

I reply personally, usually the same day.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Will clinicians resent being shown figures?

Some may at first. Showing clinic averages and asking for their ideas usually helps.

Should we tie pay to these measures?

Be careful. Start with transparency. Linking pay can distort clinical decisions.

Which number matters most?

Usually session utilisation, because empty slots carry full cost.

How do we explain insurer rules?

Use real anonymised examples of rejected claims and what would have prevented them.

How often should we share figures?

Monthly, briefly, with a fuller review each quarter.

Last reviewed: 30 October 2026

The Solvable community

You're not the only one with this problem.

One problem solved every week, on WhatsApp.

Join the community

One message a week. No sales messages. Reply STOP any time.

The short answer

Do it yourself: step by step

1Pick the numbers that matter2 hours · £0

2Show the numbers by clinician2 hours a month · £0

3Run a short session1 session · £0

4Explain insurer rules1 hour · £0

5Agree changes together1 meeting · £0

6Review quarterly1 hour a quarter · £0

Monthly clinician dashboard

Common mistakes

Answer eight quick questions and I'll show you where your clinicians are missing the numbers

What I need from you

What you get

Check where you stand

What's this costing you?Optional: work it out with your own numbers

How we worked this outMethod, formula and assumptions

Suppliers who solve this3 suppliers. No one pays to be listed

Why this keeps happening

What it leads to

Evidence

Want a hand? I'll look at your situation and tell you the three things I'd tackle first.

Frequently asked questions

Will clinicians resent being shown figures?

Should we tie pay to these measures?

Which number matters most?

How do we explain insurer rules?

How often should we share figures?

You're not the only one with this problem.